Gotland vs Jacob Wool for Yarn Spinning
I’ve always loved the color of natural grey wool. It’s quiet, nuanced, and never flat, the kind of color that rewards looking twice. Recently, I found myself admiring two skeins that, at first glance, felt surprisingly similar: both naturally grey, both beautifully spun, both clearly made with care. But the longer I looked, the more their differences revealed themselves, especially in the way the yarn caught the light and how the fabric wanted to hang.
That contrast, subtle but unmistakable, is what led me back to Gotland and Jacob. Both are heritage breeds, and both produce stunning natural grey wool, but their shine, structure, and drape tell very different stories once you start working with them.
If you’re choosing between Gotland and Jacob, you’re basically deciding what kind of chaos you want in your life. Both are heritage breeds with strong personalities, and both show up frequently in handspun yarn. They just behave very differently on the wheel, for reasons that make a lot of sense once you understand where each fiber comes from.
If you’re choosing between Gotland and Jacob, you’re basically deciding what kind of chaos you want in your life. Both are heritage breeds with personality, but they behave very differently on the wheel.
Gotland Wool
Breed background
Jacob sheep are an ancient British heritage breed, with roots that likely predate Roman Britain. Their name comes from the biblical story of Jacob’s spotted and speckled sheep described in Genesis, a reference to their distinctive piebald coloring. Unlike breeds developed specifically for fine wool production, Jacobs were traditionally kept as hardy, multipurpose farm sheep valued for resilience rather than uniformity. Their frequent multi-horned genetics and highly variable fleeces reflect this history, resulting in wool that is diverse in texture and unmistakably rustic.
Vibe: Medieval goblin with opinions (in a good way)
Vibe: Medieval goblin with opinions (in a good way)
Staple & Structure
Medium staple (typically 3–5 inches)
Very clearly dual-coated
Locks vary a lot across the fleece
Handle & Spin
More grab, more texture, more attitude
Prefers woolen or semi-woolen prep
Rewards patience and light hands
Yarn Results
Lofty, airy yarn with visible texture
Rustic, alive, and unapologetic
Excellent stitch definition when treated kindly
Pros
Warm and breathable
Great for sweaters, mittens, and heritage-style knits
Ideal if you like yarn that looks handmade
Cons
Needs sorting and prep to shine
Can feel rough if overtwisted or poorly blended
Jacob Wool
Breed background
Jacob sheep are an ancient British heritage breed, with roots that likely predate Roman Britain. Their name comes from the biblical story of Jacob’s spotted and speckled sheep described in Genesis, a reference to their distinctive piebald coloring. Unlike breeds developed specifically for fine wool production, Jacobs were traditionally kept as hardy, multipurpose farm sheep valued for resilience rather than uniformity. Their frequent multi-horned genetics and highly variable fleeces reflect this history, resulting in wool that is diverse in texture and unmistakably rustic.
Vibe: Medieval goblin with opinions (in a good way)
Staple & Structure
Medium staple (typically 3–5 inches)
Very clearly dual-coated
Locks vary a lot across the fleece
Handle & Spin
More grab, more texture, more attitude
Prefers woolen or semi-woolen prep
Rewards patience and light hands
Yarn Results
Lofty, airy yarn with visible texture
Rustic, alive, and unapologetic
Excellent stitch definition when treated kindly
Pros
Warm and breathable
Great for sweaters, mittens, and heritage-style knits
Ideal if you like yarn that looks handmade
Cons
Needs sorting and prep to shine
Can feel rough if overtwisted or poorly blended
Side-by-Side Snapshot
FeatureGotlandJacobStaple LengthLongMediumLusterHighLow–MediumElasticityLow–ModerateModeratePrep StyleWorstedWoolen / Semi-woolenFinal LookSleek, refinedRustic, texturedSkill LevelBeginner-friendlyIntermediate+
So… which should you spin?
Choose Gotland if you want smooth drafting, visual drama, and yarn that behaves itself.
Choose Jacob if you enjoy process, texture, and yarn that feels like it came out of a historical reenactment tent.
Both are excellent. They’re just excellent at very different jobs.
If you want, we can also talk blending either of them with merino, alpaca, or silk to tame or amplify their personalities.
Why You’ll See Both at Feral Scene
Both Gotland and Jacob appear often in the Feral Scene Handspun Yarn Monthly Club. The club focuses on heritage fibers, thoughtful spinning, and supporting local spinners who understand material deeply.
Rotating through fibers like these allows members to experience how breed history, preparation, and technique shape finished yarn, while directly supporting spinners working at a small, intentional scale.
When you understand the story behind the fiber, spinning and knitting become more than just making something useful. They become a conversation between animal, spinner, and maker.
